Current turnaround: 21 days from receipt of your samples. Due to high demand, HPLC-UV peptide testing and Certificates of Analysis are taking longer than usual.

Independent Research Testing Center · 875 Innovation Drive, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA For all independent testing inquiries, email admin@novagenlaboratories.com
How a lab works

System Suitability: The Test a Lab Runs Before Yours

Before a lab measures your sample, it measures something it already knows the answer to. System suitability is that check, and it says something about the instrument on the day, not about the sample.

Novagen Analytical Labs

A system suitability test is a check that an analytical system is working properly on the day, run on a known mixture before any sample result is accepted. It asks one question. Can this instrument, with this column and this method, separate and measure what it is supposed to measure right now? If the answer is no, the sample results that follow are not trusted, however clean they look.

The test is easy to overlook because it never appears as a headline number. It sits in the background of every reliable chromatographic result. It is the reason one day's purity figure can be compared with another's. It is also one of the few places where a laboratory can show, rather than assert, that the measurement was fit for its purpose.

What a system suitability test is

A high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) system is a chain of parts: a pump, an injector, a column, a detector and software. Each part can drift. A column ages. A seal leaks slightly. A mobile phase is mixed a little off. None of these faults announces itself on the chromatogram. The peaks still appear. They are simply a little wider, a little less separated or a little less reproducible than the method assumes.

System suitability testing is the formal answer to that problem. A reference standard, or a mixture of compounds chosen to stress the separation, is injected under the method conditions. Measurements are taken from the resulting peaks and compared with pre-defined acceptance criteria. If every criterion is met, the system is considered suitable for that run. If any criterion fails, the run stops.

The test is a property of the system and method together. It is not a property of the sample. That distinction matters throughout the rest of this article.

Why it runs before the sample

A method is validated once, under controlled conditions, to show that it is capable of giving reliable results. Method validation is covered in method validation basics. Validation does not guarantee that the method performs the same way on every future day. System suitability is how that ongoing performance is confirmed.

Running it before the sample sequence has a practical logic. If the system is outside its limits, the lab finds out before spending a sample on it. It also means that the result for each sample can be tied to a documented demonstration that the system was performing as validated. Many methods also include a repeat standard injection at intervals, or at the end of the sequence, to confirm that performance did not drift partway through.

Pharmacopoeial chromatography chapters set out the expectation. The United States Pharmacopeia chapter <621> Chromatography and the European Pharmacopoeia general chapter on chromatographic separation techniques both define system suitability as an integral part of a chromatographic method. Both describe the parameters below and how they are calculated. The specific limits for a given test come from the individual method or monograph, not from the general chapter alone.

Resolution (Rs)

Resolution measures how well two adjacent peaks are separated. It compares the distance between the two peak maxima with the widths of the peaks. Two narrow peaks far apart have high resolution. Two broad peaks close together have low resolution and overlap.

This parameter matters for purity work because an impurity that sits on the shoulder of the main peak can be hidden inside it. If the method cannot separate the main component from its closest neighbour, any impurity that elutes there is counted as the main component. The reported purity is then higher than the true composition.

Resolution is usually checked on a critical pair, the two components in the standard that are hardest to separate. Methods commonly require resolution to be not less than a defined minimum, with figures such as 1.5 or 2.0 often cited as general guides. A value near 1.5 is generally treated as baseline separation of two equal peaks. The actual requirement depends on the validated method, and a method may set a different figure for good reason.

Tailing factor and symmetry

An ideal chromatographic peak is symmetrical. Real peaks often drag a tail on the trailing edge. The tailing factor, sometimes called the asymmetry or symmetry factor, quantifies this. In the pharmacopoeial approach it is calculated from the peak width and the front half-width measured at a defined height, commonly 5 per cent of the peak height. Recent revisions of the USP chapter have changed some of the terminology and formulas, so a lab should apply the version that its method specifies.

Tailing matters for two reasons. First, it makes integration less certain. Where a tail merges into the baseline, the software has to decide where the peak ends, and that decision changes the reported area. Second, a tail can bury a small neighbouring peak. Basic peptides are prone to tailing on silica-based columns through secondary interactions, so this check is meaningful for peptide work.

A value close to 1.0 indicates a symmetrical peak. Methods typically set an upper limit, and a figure of 2.0 is often quoted as a general ceiling. The validated method defines the limit that applies. Where a method already controls precision through replicate injections, the symmetry check is sometimes not applied, depending on how the method is written.

Theoretical plates (N)

The plate count describes column efficiency. The term comes from an older model that pictured the column as a stack of small equilibrium stages. It remains a useful number. A column with a high plate count produces narrow peaks for its retention time. A column with a falling plate count produces broader peaks.

Plate count is calculated from the retention time of a peak and its width, either at the baseline or at half height depending on the formula in use. Because it depends on both, it falls when peaks broaden. Broadening can come from a worn column, a void at the column inlet, excessive tubing volume or a poorly chosen mobile phase.

Plate count is rarely the only criterion, because it is not a direct measure of separation. A high number does not guarantee that the critical pair is resolved. It is best read as an early indicator that the column is ageing. Methods that specify a minimum plate count do so against the efficiency the method was validated with.

Injection repeatability

Repeatability asks whether the system gives the same answer when asked the same question. A standard solution is injected several times, commonly five or six replicates, and the peak areas are compared. The spread is expressed as the relative standard deviation (%RSD): the standard deviation divided by the mean, as a percentage.

This check covers the injector, the pump and the detector together. An injector that draws inconsistent volumes, a bubble in the pump or an unstable detector lamp all show up as scatter in the areas. Since purity and content are both calculated from peak areas, scatter in the areas is scatter in the result.

Typical limits for assay-type work are in the range of 1 to 2 per cent RSD, and the replicate number and limit are set by the method. Tighter limits are used where the method needs to detect small differences. Looser limits are accepted at low concentrations, where noise contributes more. No single figure fits every method.

Retention factor and signal-to-noise

Two further checks appear in many methods.

  • Retention factor (k') compares how long a compound is held on the column with how long an unretained compound takes to pass through. It confirms that the peak of interest is retained enough to be separated from the solvent front and from unretained material. A peak that elutes too close to the front can be contaminated by anything else that is not retained. The method sets the acceptable range.
  • Signal-to-noise (S/N) compares the height of a peak with the noise of the baseline. It is used where the method must detect or quantify small peaks, such as impurities near a reporting threshold. A common convention treats a ratio of about 10 as the level at which a peak can be quantified with reasonable confidence, and a lower ratio as the level at which it can only be detected. The method states the figure it requires and the standard solution it is measured on.

Neither is universal. A method for an assay may not include signal-to-noise at all, while a related substances method usually will.

What system suitability cannot tell you

A passing system suitability result is a statement about the system. It is a necessary condition for a valid result, not a sufficient one.

  • It does not validate the sample. The standard behaving correctly does not show that the sample is what the label says.
  • It does not prove that every impurity is detected. Compounds that do not absorb at the detection wavelength, or that co-elute, can pass through a suitable system unseen.
  • It does not make the method appropriate. A system can pass suitability for a method that was never capable of separating the impurities that matter. That is a validation question.
  • It does not describe safety. Purity is composition, a measurement of what proportion of the detected material is the target compound. It is not a statement about whether a product is safe to use.

The same reasoning explains why two laboratories can report different purity figures for similar material. Differences in method, column, detection and integration all contribute, as set out in why labs report different purity. System suitability makes each lab's own result defensible. It does not make two methods equivalent.

What to look for on a report

System suitability results are often not printed on a short certificate. They sit in the underlying raw data and the lab's records. That is reasonable, but it means the reader should know what a lab ought to be able to show on request.

  • A named method, with the acceptance criteria that apply to it.
  • Evidence that the criteria were met for the run that produced the sample result.
  • A reference standard of known identity used to establish the system response. See reference standards in peptide testing for why that standard matters.
  • A chromatogram that can be read against those criteria, as described in how to read a chromatogram.

An accredited laboratory is expected to document its suitability criteria and to act on failures, and a reader can reasonably ask any laboratory how it does so. The test itself is simple in concept. Its value comes from being applied consistently and from a failed result being allowed to stop the run.

Novagen is a third-party analytical laboratory. It reports what was measured in the sample submitted, and a certificate describes that sample and nothing beyond it. Issued certificates can be checked against the public register at the verification page. Current quoted turnaround is 21 days from receipt of samples. Questions about method or reporting can be sent to admin@novagenlaboratories.com.

Common questions

What is a system suitability test in HPLC?

A system suitability test (SST) is a set of checks run on a known standard or mixture, using the same method and instrument that will analyse the sample. It confirms that the system is performing well enough on that day for the results to be trusted. Typical checks are resolution, tailing factor, theoretical plates and the repeatability of replicate injections.

What are the main system suitability parameters?

The common parameters are resolution between adjacent peaks, tailing factor or symmetry, theoretical plate count, the relative standard deviation of replicate injections, and sometimes the retention factor and signal-to-noise ratio. Which ones apply, and the acceptance limits, are set by the validated method or the relevant monograph.

What happens if a system suitability test fails?

The run is not accepted. Sample results obtained under a failed system suitability cannot be reported as valid. The cause is investigated, for example a degraded column, a fault in the pump or injector, or a badly prepared mobile phase. The fault is corrected and the sequence is repeated.

Does passing system suitability mean the sample is pure?

No. System suitability shows that the instrument and method were performing adequately on a known standard. It says nothing direct about the sample. Purity is a separate measurement taken from the sample chromatogram, and purity describes composition, not safety.